Welcome pie lovers!

Have an allergy, aversion, or special pie predilection? We love a challenge: email or call us at 718-717-8280 with your bespoke/custom order today! We can accommodate most requests with just 2-3 days' notice (sometimes less!). Also, although our cream pies are not eligible for long-distance shipping, we've tested and perfected baked, custard versions of our bestselling flavors so everyone (even vegans) can enjoy them at home! If your delivery area is outside of Manhattan/Brooklyn, you'll receive a custard version automatically. Unless specified otherwise, all our pies measure nine inches, and serve approximately 8-10 people.

1 - 8 of 8 items
Sort By:

FREE SHIPPING on orders over $75

Please note: as we do not operate a storefront, pick-ups are only available on local market days; opt for local delivery in Manhattan/Brooklyn (flat rate fixed) or national (Fedex or USPS overnight) shipping to ensure prompt arrival. 

Special thanks to The NY Times, New York magazine and Edible Brooklyn.