Key Lime Pie - Cutie Pies NYC

Cutie Pies will be on hiatus from Sept 30-Oct 11. Earliest delivery for orders placed during that time will be Friday, Oct 13. See you then!

Contact Us

Use the form on the right to contact us.

You can edit the text in this area, and change where the contact form on the right submits to, by entering edit mode using the modes on the bottom right. 

Brooklyn, NY, 11213
United States


Online shop for handcrafted pies of all sizes and show-stopping holiday effects baked in Brooklyn.

Key Lime Pie

Sliced Key Lime Pie
Custom Key Lime Pie
Classic Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

from 40.00

No wonder it's a classic: key lime pie is always a welcome treat, whether at the end of a meal, as a midnight snack or as a celebration in itself. Our classic version is a tart refresher, made with condensed milk and real key lime juice, nestled into a hand-rolled graham cracker crust temptingly spiced with cinnamon and honey. 

Want to switch things up? Opt for chocolate cookie crust and a layer of melted semisweet chocolate on the bottom, or filling studded with ripe, juicy blackberries!

To place an order with less than 48 hours' notice or for larger quantities, catering inquiries or party orders, please email for more details. Please allow extra time (at least 5-7 days) for custom orders.

Dietary Requirements: